Motor Trend Compares the Tiguan and Forester Hybrid 

Motor Trend evaluated the 2026 Tiguan, redesigned in 2025, and the Forester Hybrid, which emerged around the same time, and compared the two. It may be odd to compare a hybrid and a non-hybrid model, but the magazine was intrigued by how both models are targeting the same customer from different directions. This Bud Brown Volkswagen post shows how the comparison went. 

The comparison included the 2025 Forester Touring Hybrid (the top model) and the 2026 Tiguan SE R-Line 4MOTION (the top model before the more powerful SER R-Line). Prices as tested were $45,210 for the Forester and $41,070 for the Tiguan, giving the Tiguan a value advantage. 

Power for both models is comparable. The Forester uses the naturally aspirated 2.5-liter Boxer-4 engine found in several Subaru models, combined with a version of Toyota’s synergy hybrid system featuring two motors, producing 194 horsepower (torque figure not provided). The drivetrain is paired with a continuously variable transmission that sends power through Subaru’s mechanical all-wheel drive system. 

The Tiguan has a 2.0-liter turbocharged inline-4 engine producing 201 horsepower and 221 lb-ft of torque. The engine is paired with an 8-speed automatic transmission that sends power to all four wheels via the 4Motion system.

In summarizing the overall impression, Motor Trend states, “The Tiguan shines with its GTI-like charisma, while the Subaru’s settled ride keeps everyone comfortable.” They noted that while the Forester’s motors help it off the line, “Once the electric assist fades and the gas engine is doing most of the work, the Subaru feels as if it has trouble maintaining momentum.” They contrast this with the Tiguan, which they describe as “…eager to keep pulling, much like a Golf GTI. Gone is the lag found in the previous-generation model, with the new Tiguan seeming noticeably sportier.”

On the road, the two models further reflected their brand’s image. “On the twisty roads of Agoura Hills, California, the Tiguan showed sharper body control, while the Forester’s suspension handled road imperfections better.” 

When comparing a hybrid and a non-hybrid model, the hybrid will shine in fuel economy, and there are no surprises. The Tiguan has a 25 combined mpg rating, while the Forester is rated at 35. Those who prioritize fuel economy should note that Volkswagen plans to introduce a hybrid Tiguan in 2027. 

When it comes to space, both do well, with the Tiguan having the edge in rear leg and headroom, plus 6.1 more cubic feet behind the seats. There is a negligible cargo-size difference when the rear seats are folded. 

The magazine had issues with the previous Forester and Tiguan infotainment systems. However, the redesigned Tiguan brought an all-new system. The Forester retains its old system, which they describe as “slow to wake up, has seriously delayed responses, and its visuals feel dated.” The vertical screen isn’t well utilized when using horizontal Apple CarPlay or Android Auto interfaces, which makes the line of climate controls on the bottom edge longer and harder to reach. Even Subaru has recognized the issue and given the new Outback an all-new system, but the Forester soldiers on with the old one. 

They were much happier with the Tiguan’s 12.9-inch horizontal-format screen, though they aren’t fond of the sliding controls for some climate functions. Overall, however, they found the Tiguan’s dash much more contemporary and sophisticated than the Forester’s, with superior-looking and feeling materials. They also appreciate how relocating the transmission control to a steering column stalk opened up space on the center console.  

“We prefer the Tiguan’s modern, contemporary style. Volkswagen did an excellent job upgrading its compact SUV’s cabin, equipping it with modern tech and a fresh, appealing design. The Forester’s cabin, on the other hand, is beginning to show its age, and while it recently received an update, the design no longer feels new.” 

While they recognize the importance of the Forester hybrid’s efficiency, “the Tiguan still stood out more clearly. Its spacious cabin, modern technology, and fun-to-drive character give it the edge, while the Forester’s dated cabin design, languid feel, and aging tech ultimately hold it back.” 

With the Tiguan coming out ahead against one of the category’s stalwarts, perhaps it’s time for you to check out the sophisticated and sporty Tiguan at Bud Brown Volkswagen, conveniently located by I-35 in Olathe, Kansas, and home of the Bud Brown Advantage Lifetime Limited Warranty.